|
New!
Search All Of My Articles By Topic With Quick and Easy Links
If you like these articles,
please link to them, instead of copying them. Thank you.
Green Living
Now News, Edition Twenty-Eight
1.
Which Food Is Better For Our Environment And Us:
Local (Conventional) or (Trucked-In) Organic?

By Amy Todisco
Local or organic, is this our only
choice? Some argue that it is, but I think not. Why not local organic?
Or, homegrown organic? If you are concerned about health, yours
and the farm workers, isn't organic always the choice? But, what
if local organic or homegrown isn't an option, is it more important
to support your local economy?
Let me go right to what I believe are the best choices, and then
take a look at all of the options.
For me the ideal choice is homegrown organic and trading
with my friends and neighbors for their organic food-- the things
I don't grow myself. That's what my Aunt Jojo used to do in Morgantown
Virginia. Nobody grew tomatoes like Jojo. They were so flavorful,
red, and sweet. I haven't had any that good since. All of her veggies
tasted great, and her dinner table was always graced with colorful
fresh homegrown flowers. She also made her own soap and dried herbs
and garlic from her garden. She traded for chicken from a neighbor,
and rarely entered a supermarket (well, maybe that's because Uncle
Harry was the one to go from time to time.) She also canned, dried
and froze food from her garden for the rest of the year. That was
a sustainable way to live. My friend, Kelly, is doing that today-in
Northwestern Vermont. What's even more impressive is that they're
on a renewable energy system--they aren't hooked up to the electrical
grid. Oh, and Kelly sells raw organic milk from her family cow,
Spring. I love that stuff. Complete with probiotics and enzymes.
I've been drinking raw organic milk for several years and I feel
good. Another neighbor who is lactose intolerant can drink raw milk,
but not pasteurized and homogenized milk, even if it's organic.
(See why raw organic milk
is a healthful option.)
A good second option is locally grown organic (within a
100 mile radius of your home), especially if it's from a small family
farm. I believe that local means, locally grown in season. Growing
in a greenhouse, unless it's powered with renewable energy, is very
energy intensive-not good for the environment. In addition to the
food I grow myself, I buy from the Jubilee organic farm 2 miles
down the road. It's amazing, really. I can go in to the barn at
any time of day or night, pick what I want from the refrigerator
or on one of the tables, and put the money into the cash box. Theft
has been rare-even in this day and age. What a gift. Fresh, healthy,
and totally convenient. There's a whole movement
to eat local.
There are also lots of farmer's markets all over the state of Vermont.
I bet there are some in your state too. (Find them here).
I go to those too, but find most of my food needs are fulfilled
between my garden and Jubilee. Up the road we have another organic
farm where they sell grass fed beef, pork and chicken. Great stuff,
a bit pricey. (I don't eat beef, but I've heard it's tasty. Grass
fed is much better for the animals, the environment, and us. For
more information, check this out:
http://www.foodrevolution.org/grassfedbeef.htm).
Getting to know the farmers you buy from is really important. You
can ask what their agriculture practices are. Visiting the farm,
and helping out, is even better. When we lived in Massachusetts
we joined a community supported agriculture group (CSA). We paid
a set fee up front for a certain amount of fresh, organic produce
during the growing season. The idea behind a CSA is to support the
farmer by paying up front. The only downside of a CSA is if the
weather isn't good (drought or excessive rainfall, early frost,
or some other weather event) you may not get as much food as you
had anticipated. It's really shocking to think that by the end of
the 20th Century only
2% of our population was working on farms .
So, if only 2% of the population is growing all of our food, what
does that say about the size these farms have to be? Doesn't sound
very sustainable. Though I am an eternal optimist, I can't help
but wonder what will happen to our food supply if the weather gets
even more bizarre and makes growing food outside difficult, or if
there is a purposeful attack on our food supply. Concentrating our
food growing into a few mega farms, whether they are organic or
conventional does not make sense. I really like farm fresh food
from small family farms.
But, if you don't have any land to grow on, no organic neighbors
growing nearby, no farmer's markets or CSA's, or you don't have
green thumb, then what are your choices? And, how do these choices
compare as far as human health, the environment, and reducing our
carbon footprint (global warming/climate change)?
Fossil fuels:
There's no question that conventionally grown food uses a lot of
fossil fuels. 19% of fossil fuels is used for field machinery, and
16% for transporting crops (The numbers are from 1994. Source:
http://www.fromthewilderness.com/free/ww3/100303_eating_oil.html)
Apparently, shipping food by rail was more energy efficient, but
in recent decades there's been a switch to trucking, which uses
a lot of fuel. Then there's the energy needed to refrigerate the
food. We also need to consider the materials, energy and time to
package the food.
When I consider the fossil fuels used to truck an organic tomato
to Vermont from California in the winter and the fossil fuels and
other chemicals used to grow a conventional tomato in Vermont during
the growing season, it may be a wash. But, since I always think
of health first, I still come out in favor of the organic tomato
because I choose to avoid chemicals in my food. I also don't like
the idea of farm workers on conventional farms doused with pesticides
and other chemicals. If I am comparing an organic tomato from California
or a conventional one in the winter, it's a no brainer, I chose
the organic. Though the fossil fuel used to truck it to me is the
same, the fossil fuels used on the large conventional farm in the
form of pesticides, farming equipment and synthetic fertilizer pushes
it over the top.
But, I also have to ask the question, how large is the organic
farm in California? Are they really adhering to strict organic practices?
And, what about the conventional local farm. How conventional are
they? Do they use chemical pesticides and fertilizers? Or do they
farm sustainably but just can't afford to pay for the organic certification?
Consider that since the USDA has gotten involved in regulating organic
farms, they've tried to lower the standards for organic by including
fertilizer made from sewage sludge, allowing genetically engineered
seeds, and using food irradiation. Thankfully, we the public spoke
out so fervently against this that it did not pass.
Health:
Independent studies are coming out showing that some organic food
is healthier than it's conventional counterparts. A recent study
from UC Davis (6/23/07) showed that the two flavonoids: quercetin
and kaempferol were 79% and 97% higher in dried organic tomatoes
versus dried conventional tomatoes over a ten-year period. And,
the levels of flavonoids increased over time in the organic samples
and not the conventional ones.
A University of California Davis study found that a sample of organic
kiwis had more nutrients than the non-organic sample. (http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/abstract/114202162/ABSTRACT)
In a Warsaw (Poland) Agriculture University study found a sample
of organic tomatoes to contain more vitamin C, beta-carotene and
flavonoids than non-organic tomatoes (http://orgprints.org/9944/)
And, yet another Warsaw Agriculture study found organic apple puree
to contain more phenols, flavonoids, and vitamin C than non-organic
apple puree (http://orgprints.org/9943/)
There is also a study in France that found organic peaches to be
higher in polyphenols than non-organic peaches. (http://orgprints.org/9855/)
Even if conventional foods don't turn out to be as dangerous as
organic advocates claim, several recent studies have suggested that
organic foods contain higher levels of vitamins than their conventionally
grown counterparts. In a paper published in October in the Journal
of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, a team from the University of
California, Davis, demonstrates that organically grown tomatoes
have significantly more vitamin C than conventional tomatoes.
In the UK paper, The Telegraph, the article, "It's official:
organic really is better", it says this: "This sort of
research is music to our ears," says Robin Maynard, campaigns
director at the Soil Association, which promotes organic farming.
"We know from a study carried out between 1940 and 1991 by
the now defunct Ministry of Agriculture that UK-grown produce has
shown a 12 to 76 per cent drop in a range of key nutrients
Non-organic
farming uses more than 400 active ingredients, some of which prove
to be so toxic they end up being banned. The founding ethos of the
Soil Association is that healthy soil means healthy plants, healthy
animals and healthy people. When a reputable study like this is
published, people's gut feeling that organic production methods
are right is backed up by science." http://www.telegraph.co.uk/wine/main.jhtml?xml=/wine/2007/07/14/edorganic114.xml
No discussion of food and health are complete without mentioning
fast food, something Americans have become addicted to. Did you
know that 34% of the total food consumed in the U.S. is fast food.
Americans consume approximately 3,600 food calories per day. The
world average is 2700 calories/day. Eating all that junky fast food
devoid of nutrition makes our bodies want to consume more food to
meet our nutritional needs. No wonder we have an obesity problem.
For more on fast food, read the book and/or see the movie, Fast
Food Nation, by Eric Schlosser and Richard Linklateror, and
see the movie, "Supersize Me" written by Morgan Spurlock.
Taste & Freshness:
How fresh is the food once it arrives at the distribution point?
One estimate I heard was that produce is at least one week old by
the time it reaches the supermarket shelves. How fresh is it by
the time we eat it? What's left in the way of nutrition? Some conventional
foods are waxed or artificially colored to appear fresher, and irradiated
to supposedly kill bacteria that contributes to spoilage. Genetically
engineered food is designed in part to stay fresher longer. Good
for the retailer, not so good for the consumer. So, even if your
conventional food looks fresher, chances are it has been synthetically
preserved in some way. Organic foods tend to spoil faster because
they are usually picked at the peak of ripeness. Many conventional
foods ripen after they've been picked, which is why conventional
tomatoes in the winter taste like golf balls (not that I've actually
eaten golf balls...)
Locally grown food is usually sold within 24 hours of being picked.
Food picked at the peak of ripeness often tastes much better and
contains more nutrients.
Supporting the local economy:
Buying locally, whether organic or conventional keeps your food
dollars in your community. Buying from a chain supermarket or box
store, who knows how much of the money stays in your area? Buying
directly from the farmer cuts out the middleman and gives the retail
price of the food to the farmer.
Preserve open spaces:
This is what the Grinning Planet website says about protecting
open spaces, "Communities across the country have found that
protecting open space, parks, and farm land is a strategy that can
be used to strengthen existing communities, attract businesses,
and avoid the costs of urban and suburban sprawl. As part of a package
of smart growth programs and policies, communities that offer a
high quality of life (including well maintained neighborhood parks
and regional park systems) consistently attract and retain businesses."
(http://www.grinningplanet.com/2005/02-15/farm-land-sprawl-smart-growth-article.htm)
From an environmental and human health perspective, it makes sense
that an organic farm would be a healthier choice than a conventional
farm.
Genetic Diversity:
Most U.S. produce is grown in California, Washington and Florida.
So, unless you live in one of those states, it has to be trucked
to your local supermarket. Often the varieties chosen are selected
for their ability to withstand the harvesting equipment and extended
travel. What happens to the taste? This is the case for both organic
and conventional. There is more likely to be a larger variety with
locally grown produce, which means more flavor. I love growing heirloom
varieties. Here's what Marie Hofer of HGTV Ideas Magazine says about
heirlooms, "These days 90 percent of the world's food supply
comes from just 20 species. Scientists fear that when a new pest
threatens a species, an heirloom variety that could have been resistant
may already have disappeared."
So, get out there and buy that fresh local organic produce before
the season ends! Bon Appetit.
http://www.grist.org/advice/books/2006/05/18/fromartz/index.html
http://www.slate.com/id/2138176/
http://www.boston.com/news/globe/ideas/articles/2007/07/22/the_localvores_dilemma/?page=1
http://www.organicconsumers.org/articles/article_6358.cfm
http://archpedi.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/161/8/792
http://www.fromthewilderness.com/free/ww3/100303_eating_oil.html
http://www.foodrevolution.org/grassfedbeef.htm
http://rawfoodnetwork.com/
http://www.foodrevolution.org/our_food_our_future_print.htm
http://www.vermontlocalvore.org/
http://www.foodroutes.org/whycare2.jsp
http://www.hgtv.com/hgtv/gl_plants_other/article/0,1785,HGTV_3609_1395172,00.htm
http://www.grinningplanet.com/2005/02-15/farm-land-sprawl-smart-growth-article.htm
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/06/opinion/06mcwilliams.html
http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/abstract/114202162/ABSTRACT
2.
Good News...

By Amy Todisco
Monsanto's rBGH hormone is being
driven out of the market. Hurray. From the Organic Consumer's Association,
"The synthetic hormone is banned in most of the world, due
to its links to prostate and breast cancer. Although it is still
being injected into thousands of dairy herds in the U.S., grassroots
pressure from health-minded consumers and public interest groups,
like the OCA, have caused Starbucks, Chipotle, and many supermarket
chains to put pressure on their dairy suppliers to stop using the
drug. "
Read more here: http://www.organicconsumers.org/rbghlink.cfm
3. Not So Good News...

Think commercials on TV don't influence
our children? In a new study in the Archives of Pediatrics &
Adolescent Medicine, researchers found that 4 out of 5 preschool
age kids said they preferred the flavor of foods served in McDonald's
packaging versus the exact same foods served in packaging without
the McDonald's brand. The more TV sets in the home and the more
frequently they ate at McDonalds had a greater effect. Read more:
http://archpedi.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/161/8/792
It's free to subscribe
to my monthly newsletter.
Sign up for Green Living Expert, Amy Todisco's,
free E-newsletter and you'll receive well-researched,
useful, newsworthy information, and some free surprises,
to help you "green" up your indoor spaces and improve
your life. Your e-mail address will never be shared, rented
or sold. Your privacy is guaranteed.
Sign up for our FREE newsletter now:
Any Questions? Don't hesitate to contact me,
Amy Todisco,
Editor in Chief, and Owner of Green Living Now, LLC,
at: amy@greenlivingnow.com
|